Audiobook Review: The Chosen Path by Jason Hershey
The Chosen Path
Series: Thelonious Mitchell #2
Author: Jason Hershey
Narrator: Jacob Ross
Published: May 3, 2017
Audiobook: 1 hour 47 minutes
Reviewed By: Jessica
Dates Read: May 4, 2026, re-listen: May 18, 2026
Jessica’s Rating: 4 stars
Book Description:
Thelonious “Theo” Mitchell thought he’d finally found his spark. After losing his mother and best friend, Draven, college was supposed to be his fresh start—a chance to play football, chase his dreams, and maybe even fall in love.
Then he meets Sabrinna. Beautiful, broken, and guarded, she becomes the person who makes him feel whole again. For the first time since his mother’s death, Theo allows himself to hope, to trust, to open his heart completely.
But Sabrinna carries wounds of her own—a painful past that makes her push away the one person who truly sees her. As their relationship spirals through passion, confusion, and heartbreak, Theo must confront an impossible question: How do you hold on to someone who’s determined to let you go?
When a devastating encounter forces Theo to face the truth about their relationship, he’s left with a choice that will define his future. Walking away might break him, but staying could destroy him.
Raw, honest, and achingly real, The Chosen Path is the second book in the Theo series—a powerful story about first love, self-discovery, and learning that sometimes the most important person you need to save is yourself.
Jessica’s Review:
Jason Hershey is back with the second novella in the Thelonious Mitchell series. Theo is starting his college career which includes playing football. Of course a girl comes into the picture, so we have a novella that includes Theo’s first love and everything that encompasses. The novella is realistic in that not everyone gets a ‘happy ever after’, but that is life and Theo takes life as it comes to him. He learns about life and experiences some self- discovery and that sometimes that he himself is the most important person.
I didn’t like Sabrinna from the beginning, something about her did not sit right with me. Because of that I felt more emotions for Theo as he experienced his first love. In some ways I think I identified with Theo’s experience, just a female perspective. And I am just attached to Theo after To Die To Live!
I have to add that I really love the cover to this one! Life is a journey for us all and we have to choose our life path and take what it brings. The cover is just perfect for this part of Theo’s life. I myself have experienced going down a different life path than expected with my divorce almost two years ago.
We have a new narrator with this story, Jacob Ross. Theo comes off older with Ross’s narration, and his voice felt perfect for portraying Theo this time around. The only issue I had with the audiobook was the transition between chapters. When one chapter ended and the next began, it felt pieced together too quickly. For me, the narration needed an extra second or two of pause before Ross started the next chapter and said “Chapter X,” and went into the new chapter.
The Chosen Path is a quick read/listen and Hershey just brings Theo’s story to life for me. Now, be forewarned that this one ends in a bit of a cliffhanger as Theo makes a decision for himself. This novella was written back in 2017, and fortunately I do not have to wait years to see what happens next in Theo’s life as the third novella will be coming out very soon!
Many thanks to Jason Hershey for sending me an audiobook copy to listen to and review!
Purchase Links:
Amazon US
Amazon UK
Audiobook Review: To Die To Live by Jason Hershey
To Die To Live
Series: Thelonious Mitchell #1
Author: Jason Hershey
Narrator: Justin James
Published: October 17, 2017
Audiobook: 1 hour 11 minutes
Reviewed By: Jessica
Date Listened To: May 2, 2026
Jessica’s Rating: 5 stars
Book Description:
Thelonious “Theo” Mitchell is a down-on-his-luck teenager, wandering aimlessly through life with no desire or focus. When tragedy strikes, he is taken in by his aunt and uncle. Thrown into a new school with unfamiliar surroundings, he befriends the class “troublemaker”. After yet another tragedy, will Theo fall victim to life, or use the tragedy as a spark and motivation to embrace all that life has to offer?
Jessica’s Review:
This novella is a debut and it was powerful! I was pulled in and attached to Theo from the beginning. He is young and has already been dealt a hard life. He has gone through a hard loss and taken in by his aunt and uncle. A new place means new changes and also challenges. Teens can be brutal, even more so to ‘the new guy’ who doesn’t fit in. But then Theo meets and eventually becomes friends with Draven, and they bond over similarities. What happens over the course of the novella shows what some kids go through and life is not easy for everyone and the hardships that can affect someone for their life.
I listened to the audio version and it is just one hour 11 minutes long, but Hershey packs so much into it: The importance of close friendship, heartache, loss, and determination to live the life we are given in spite of what happens to us. The narrator Justin James brought Theo to life for me!
This novella was written nine years ago and some parts of it have aged: Teens mostly do not use Facebook anymore. They have Snapchat, TikTok, and I am sure other apps that I am not familiar with. It’s not a negative, times and technology just change!
I look forward to more stories involving Theo and what happens next in his life.
I received an Audible copy from the author in exchange for a review. Thank you so much! I enjoyed my introduction to Theo.
Purchase Links:
Amazon US
Amazon UK
Book Review: The First Wish of Mr. Murray McBride by Joe Siple
The First Wish of Mr. Murray McBride
Series: Murray McBride #3
Author: Joe Siple
Published: March 18, 2025
Kindle: 266 pages
Reviewed By: Jessica
Dates Read: March 19- April 20, 2025
Jessica’s Rating: 5 stars
Book Description:
The prequel to the Murray McBride series—by the author of the beloved USA Today international bestselling novel The Five Wishes of Mr. Murray McBride.
The day before Murray McBride moves Jenny, his beloved wife of eighty years, into a memory care center, she convinces him to search for a case her grandfather buried long ago, said to contain “a treasure worth more than gold.” With the help of some new friends, Murray and Jenny retrace their steps from years before. Over the course of the day, Murray tenderly retells their love story—how they met, the challenges they faced and overcame, and their initial attempt at the quest.
But the closer they get to the treasure, the more clearly Murray remembers why they abandoned the search the first time. With the exhilarating discovery at hand, Murray must decide whether to unearth the treasure, even if it means bringing up painful events from the past.
Jessica’s Review:
Joe Siple, you got me again with this prequel learning Murray and his wife Jenny’s love story. I didn’t cry this time, but came close to it, especially as I got towards the end!
The First Wish takes place in both 1910 and 1996. In 1910, Murray and Jenny meet while in school; in 1996, it is the day before Jenny is being moved into a memory care center due to her decline with Alzheimer’s. Also in 1996, Jenny is 99-years-old and Murray is 98- years old. They have also been married for just over 80 years. What a life they both have lived!
Both 1910 and 1996 are filled with a variety of emotions. I was fully invested in both storylines as I just adored Murray in The Five Wishes and loved reading about Murray and Jenny’s meeting and eventual love story that covers 80 years. The reader also feels emotions with the dealings of Alzheimer’s/Dementia of both Murray as the caregiver and Jenny as the one suffering from the disease. Siple handles this well.
Both timelines deal with a journey to find a treasure that is ‘worth more than gold’. I was intrigued in multiple ways: First, will the treasure even be located? Two, what could be worth more than gold?!?! Chapter 11 through the end really got to me emotionally. What was mentioned was dealing with life throwing you curveballs: 2024 was a year that threw a huge curveball for me, but I am doing much better now in 2025.
Many thanks to Joe Siple for bringing these characters to life in this series. This is one reader who really appreciated reading these books. And it is thanks to a book club that I am in for introducing me to The Five Wishes of Mr. Murray McBride. I would not have heard of this book without that book club.
Purchase Links:
Amazon US
Amazon UK